More on Error

I have written about error before, but she still follows me like my shadow. I have therefore decided to consider how to deal with her rather than continue my futile efforts to escape. Familiarity has not bred contempt, exactly, but it has supplied plenty of material.
There is no universally accepted list of all human errors. They can be classified by their causes, the activities involved, our awareness of them, or their consequences. The categories overlap because a single mistake can qualify for membership in several clubs. A useful broad definition of error is a departure from what is true, intended, appropriate, or effective.
In classifying error, I am certain to commit the error of leaving something out. This realization only ennobles my effort-or so I choose to believe. In truth, some omissions will be deliberate. I am too lazy to catalogue every way of getting things wrong, and an exhaustive account would exhaust the reader long before it exhausted the subject.
Before proceeding, we should distinguish error from misfortune. A sensible decision can produce a bad result, while a foolish one can succeed through luck. The outcome alone does not establish the quality of the decision. We must consider what was reasonably knowable when it was made. Otherwise, the lucky fool becomes an authority and the unlucky expert becomes an idiot. Both transformations occur regularly.
The first practical distinction concerns our awareness of error. Leading the pack is the mistake you make inadvertently and do not recognize until someone gently, or with conspicuous pleasure, throws it in your face. Your immediate temptation may be to explain why it was not really a mistake. Resist it. If the correction is sound, acknowledge it, repair what needs repairing, and move on.
Then there is the error you recognize but nobody else appears to notice. Here many people compound a small mistake by conducting a public inquiry into it. A harmless conversational stumble does not require a press conference. People are sufficiently occupied with their own problems that they will probably forget yours unless you keep reminding them.
Silence, however, is appropriate only when nothing needs correcting. A wrong figure in a report or a false statement on which someone may rely should be corrected even if nobody has complained. If your error has caused harm, apologize and make whatever repair or restitution is possible. Moving on means abandoning needless self-reproach, not abandoning an unfinished obligation. Once the matter is settled, there is usually no reason to keep repeating the apology.
The next distinction is trickier: doing something consciously is not the same as consciously doing something wrong. A person may deliberately choose an action while sincerely, though mistakenly, believing it correct. That is an error of judgment, a beast most of us keep around like a pet dog or cat. Someone who knows a statement is false and nevertheless offers it as true is practicing deception. Deliberate deception calls for accountability. An honest mistake may instead require better information, clearer instructions, or a better procedure. Punishment is not a universal cure.
Having considered whether we recognize our errors, we can ask where they originate.
Errors of knowledge arise from missing or false information. Nobody knows everything, although some people conceal this limitation more successfully from themselves than from others. Ignorance becomes particularly troublesome when it is mistaken for expertise. A person can reason impeccably from a false premise and arrive at an impressive conclusion that has no useful connection to reality.
Factual errors belong here. Getting a date wrong, confusing two people, or attributing a remark to someone who never said it are familiar examples. Misattributed quotations circulate so freely that repetition begins to pass for authentication. The well-read and well-educated are hardly immune. Indeed, their credentials can help a doubtful quotation travel farther. A collection of these verbal orphans would supply another article, provided I could identify their parents.
Memory errors overlap with factual errors but describe a mechanism rather than merely an incorrect result. We forget, combine separate events, transfer a remark from one speaker to another, and sometimes acquire a vivid recollection of something that never happened. Confidence does not guarantee accuracy. A sizable proportion of us are headed toward extended residence in this house of error, though younger people should not imagine that they lack a key. Knowingly inventing a recollection, of course, belongs under fabrication rather than faulty memory.
Errors of perception occur when information is available but is overlooked or misinterpreted. We see what we expect, miss what we are not looking for, and recognize familiar patterns before checking whether they actually fit. Reading a report inattentively can be as misleading as misreading an instrument. The evidence has arrived; we simply have not received it correctly.
Errors of reasoning begin when we draw conclusions the evidence does not justify. We confuse sequence with causation, generalize from a few examples, or assume that because two things resemble each other in one respect, they must resemble each other in every respect. An argument can also contain its conclusion disguised as a premise. This arrangement is wonderfully efficient because it allows the conclusion to dispense with independent support.
Numbers introduce further opportunities. Arithmetic can be wrong, but correct arithmetic can be equally misleading when applied to unsuitable assumptions. A percentage can mislead when the underlying population or sample size is unspecified. An average can disguise enormous variation. Several decimal places can give a guess the appearance of scientific authority. Before admiring a calculation, it helps to ask whether it answers the question that matters.
Errors of execution differ from errors of judgment. You may know exactly what to do and still do something else. Writing the wrong name on an envelope despite knowing the intended recipient is a slip; forgetting to send the letter is a lapse. Sending it to someone you mistakenly believe to be the appropriate recipient is a faulty decision. The outcomes may resemble one another, but the remedies differ. More instruction will not necessarily cure distraction, and a reminder will not repair a misunderstanding.
Another distinction separates commission from omission: doing what should not be done and failing to do what should. Commission attracts attention because someone visibly acted. Omission can remain inconspicuous until the opportunity to act has disappeared. Neither is inherently safer. Excessive caution may produce a catastrophe while preserving the comforting impression that nobody did anything wrong.
Emotional and motivational errors arise when feelings or desires distort judgment. Anger encourages disproportionate responses. Fear magnifies unlikely dangers. Wishful thinking turns an attractive possibility into an alleged probability. Pride makes correction feel like defeat. These influences need not involve dishonesty; people can sincerely believe conclusions chiefly because they want them to be true. Sincerity is an admirable quality with no guarantee of accuracy.
Groups contribute errors that individuals might have difficulty producing alone. Members suppress doubts, mistake silence for agreement, or leave responsibility to someone else. Unwelcome information may disappear on its journey up a hierarchy. An organization can also reward conduct that makes sense for each employee while undermining its collective purpose. Replacing one person will accomplish little if the incentives remain intact.
Sometimes the error lies in the goal itself. An institution may become highly efficient at an activity that serves no worthwhile purpose. It may count what is easy to measure and gradually forget what the measurement was intended to represent. Before improving a process, it is advisable to determine whether the process deserves improvement or retirement.
Finally, there is the error of refusing to correct an error. The original mistake may have been understandable. Continuing after its defects become apparent is another matter. Money and effort already invested, together with pride and reputation at stake, can make retreat intolerable. We then spend still more defending what we should abandon. The ability to change one’s mind is useful; the willingness to do so is rarer.
There are more ways to go wrong than I have the patience to describe. Classification is most useful when it helps us choose an appropriate response. Missing information calls for investigation, an execution failure may require a simpler procedure, and a harmful incentive needs changing. Not every mistake requires a confession, but every consequential mistake deserves attention. Correct it, make amends where necessary, and try not to repeat it. Thereafter, silence may once again become your friend.
And then there is the title of this piece. Say it aloud, and you may identify another category-or at least its author.
Comments
Loading